top of page

Cayo Realty Key West

Your Key West Life Starts Here.

​

There’s the Key West you visit. Then there’s the Key West you make your own. The familiar faces, the favorite spots, the everyday moments that make this island feel like home.

​

Your next chapter deserves someone who listens to what matters to you, knows the local market, and brings a clear plan to the possibilities. A place unlike anywhere else. A real estate experience centered entirely on you.

Find Your Home in Key West

From Old Town cottages to waterfront homes, every part of the island feels different. I always tell people to get off Duval and explore the little streets. I’ll help you get to know the neighborhoods and find the home that fits how you want to live.

Profile Picture

Real Estate Guidance That Goes Beyond the Sale

A pretty house is only part of the story. Before you fall in love with one, I want you to understand what comes with it—flood zones, insurance, rental rules, permits, historic-home requirements, and the realities of owning on the water.

​

​I'll help you ask the right questions, talk through your options, and make sense of the details. And after closing, you can still call me. I want you to feel at home here.

Pool in Truman Annex

Local Guidance for Your Key West Move

Wondering what living here is really like? Start with the neighborhoods, then take a look at my buyer and seller guides. When you're ready, tell me what you're hoping for. We'll take it from there.

Buyer & Seller Resources

For Buyers

Explore Key West homes, neighborhood guidance and open houses.

Check current mortgage rates

National averages from Mortgage News Daily. Your lender’s rates may vary.

For Sellers 

Planning to sell, or starting fresh after a listing expired or was cancelled?

Discover a marketing strategy designed to set your home apart.

See how I approach pricing, presentation, open houses and meeting with potential buyers. You can also request a home valuation below.

What's My Home Worth?

Curious what your Key West home could sell for? Tell me a little about it. I'll look at recent sales and what makes your property different, then we can talk about a price that makes sense. There's no obligation.

What My Clients Say

  • Ken E.

    Zainya was the listing agent for the sellers when we purchased our home, but you would’ve thought she was our agent based on how she treated us. From the beginning, she was responsive, professional, and genuinely helpful, always making sure we understood what was happening and what to expect next. She was always quick to respond to questions and never made us feel like an inconvenience. Any time something needed clarification, she explained it in a way that was easy to understand. She also helped keep timelines, vendors, and next steps organized so nothing slipped. She kept communication clear, handled details quickly, and helped keep everything moving forward, which greatly reduced stress during the purchase. It’s rare to find someone who represents one side of the transaction but still shows that level of care and respect to the buyer. If you’re looking for a real estate professional who’s organized, proactive, and easy to work with, I’d absolutely recommend Zainya.

  • Janel R.

    We got Zainya's name from a realtor friend who doesn't work in the Keys. The first time we met her, my husband and I didn't even know whether we were going to buy a place in Florida. Zainya spent a day driving us all over the Keys, even though there was no guarantee we would buy anything. We eventually settled on a home in Key West. I can't emphasize enough how great Zainya was throughout the entire process. She is exceptional. I would not buy from anyone else.

  • Art M.

    Working with Zainya turned into so much more than a real estate transaction. She was incredibly patient with me, always looked out for my best interests, and never made me feel pressured. She helped me sell my home and even found my floating home on Facebook Marketplace, simply because she knew it was exactly what I was looking for. She went far beyond what I would ever expect from a real estate agent. What means the most to me is that somewhere along the way, Zainya stopped feeling like my real estate agent and became a true friend. She is someone I trust completely, and I know she genuinely cares about the people she works with. I could not recommend her more highly.

  • Mark H.

    ​

    I’ve had the opportunity to work with Zainya on both buying and selling real estate, and I would absolutely work with her again. She is knowledgeable, responsive, patient, and always keeps the process moving without making you feel pressured.

    Zainya takes the time to understand what you actually want and gives straightforward, thoughtful advice throughout the process. She pays attention to the details, is a strong negotiator, and genuinely looks out for her clients’ best interests.

    After working with her over the years, I can say with confidence that she is someone I trust and would highly recommend to anyone buying or selling real estate in Key West.

  • Lois E.

    Zainya was the listing agent for the sellers when we purchased our home, but based on the way she treated us, you would have thought she was our agent too. From the very beginning, Zainya was incredibly responsive, professional, organized, and genuinely helpful. She was always quick to answer our questions, explain things clearly, and make sure we knew what to expect next. We never felt like we were bothering her or that any question was too small. She did a great job keeping all the moving pieces organized—from timelines and vendors to the many details that come with purchasing a home. If something needed attention, she handled it quickly and kept things moving forward, which made the entire process so much less stressful for us. What impressed us most was the level of care she showed us even though she represented the sellers. And that care didn't stop once we closed on the house. Zainya continues to stay in touch with us on a regular basis just to check in, see how we're doing, and make sure everything is going well. There’s no transaction involved and nothing she needs from us—she simply cares. That says a lot about who she is, both personally and professionally. Zainya is knowledgeable, proactive, dependable, and simply a pleasure to work with. We wouldn't hesitate to work with her again, and we would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in the Key West area.

bottom of page